They didn’t hold back with the review article.
MEOVV, the first group of girls under THE BLACK LABELThey debuted on September 6, 2024. Despite the excitement that their debut generated, their first song was not received very well by the general public or critics.
MEOVV debuted with the single “MEOW,” and while each member’s individual talents shined through, the song itself garnered negative reviews across the board. In particular, EXECone of the most important online music review magazines, recently published a very harsh article in which it reviews the song.
IZM rated “MEOW” with only one star. The first of many complaints about the song was the repetition of the “meow” sound in the song, which had no intention or meaning. The review also called it “boring” and blamed its excessive use for distracting attention from members’ voices.
In a track that is not even three minutes long, a whole minute is taken up by cat sounds that have no intention or meaning. The weightless repetition that includes the intro, outro, overdubbed chorus, and rap parts quickly becomes boring and, more importantly, takes away the most essential aspect: the members’ voices.
– MEC
The review also criticized the compositional elements of the song, specifying that “the simple combination of bass and kick drum carries the song.” IZM stated that the lack of versatility between the two verses reduced the song’s impact, further reduced by the empty section of the song intended for the dance break..
Monotonous rhythm, inaudible lyrics, empty repetition, and one-dimensional progression are all failures. Failure to realize the desired image or intended message leaves only an ambiguous form.
– MEC
According to the review, the only positive aspect of the song was Gahyeon’S vocal skills. But he also criticized the song for not being strong enough to give all the members the space to showcase their strengths. The review concluded by questioning the growing trend of K-Pop songs prioritizing virality over longevity.
Why is a catchy song that will soon be forgotten given priority over a great piece that sticks in your memory and invites you to listen to it again and again?
– MEC
Netizens are divided on this review and their opinion of “MEOW” in general. Almost two weeks after its release, many are still unimpressed by the song, while others feel that it has improved their taste over time.
- “It’s been a while since I’ve heard a song or seen a music video this boring.”
- “I’m curious to know how this song was confirmed as the title track.”
- “I can’t listen to it for more than 10 seconds, so I can’t give an overall review. I’ve tried twice, but I can’t get past that.”
- “The more I listen, the more refined and enjoyable it becomes.”
- “As you keep listening, it becomes more bearable.”
What do you think of MEOVV’s debut?
Share this post
