A recent viral discussion on social media has reignited the debate over which fourth-generation female K-pop idols are most frequently criticized for allegedly “Low EQ”, a term commonly used online to describe a perceived lack of social awareness, tact, or emotional intelligence.
Among the most frequently mentioned names were IVE’s Jang Wonyoung, aespa’s Ningning, and i-dle’s Shuhua. All three idols are among the most recognizable female stars of their generation. However, in addition to their popularity, they have also become a recurring subject of online criticism for various controversies regarding their behavior, comments, or public interactions.
Ningning by Aespa
Ningning recently found itself at the center of another wave of criticism following a livestream broadcast on Weibo. The controversy began when some viewers noticed that the live stream’s cash gift feature remained enabled throughout the broadcast. The aespa member was also criticized for allegedly promoting a weight-loss product during the stream.
The backlash intensified as online users questioned the product’s origins and certification, arguing that public figures should be more careful when discussing products that could influence young fans.
This is not the first time Ningning has faced public scrutiny. In 2022, the singer became embroiled in a debate after a video surfaced showing her covering her ears while walking past fans at a fashion event. Critics interpreted the gesture as dismissive, while supporters argued that he was simply adjusting his earpiece and that the clip lacked context.
Another controversy emerged after Ningning shared a photo of a decorative lamp shaped like a mushroom cloud. What he described as a cute item for home drew criticism among some Japanese netizens due to its perceived similarity to images associated with atomic bomb explosions. The issue resurfaced in late 2025, when aespa was announced as part of NHK’s prestigious year-end music programleading to online petitions opposing the group’s appearance.
Despite these incidents, many fans argue that many of Ningning’s controversies have been exaggerated beyond their original context.
IVE’s Jang Wonyoung
As one of the most popular female idols in K-pop today, Jang Wonyoung has long faced intense public scrutiny. Since his debut with IZ*ONE and subsequent success with IVE, almost every public appearance has attracted the attention of both supporters and critics.
Most recently, Wonyoung became the subject of controversy following her departure via Gimpo Airport. A viral clip showed the idol briefly lowering her mask during an identity verification process, leading some viewers to accuse her of being uncooperative or disrespectful to airport staff. The controversy grew enough to prompt a public complaint to airport authorities. However, officials later clarified that the identity verification process had been conducted correctly and as per regulations.
Wonyoung was also criticized after footage from a fan event showed her removing a headband and throwing it aside after a photo session. Some interpreted the action as dismissive of a fan’s gift, while others argued that the clip lacked full context.
Earlier this year, the singer faced criticism from a fan who claimed she appeared distracted during a video call event. The complaint generated significant debate online, with supporters pointing out that idols often multitask during lengthy fan sign programs.
One of the most persistent criticisms of Wonyoung involves the accusation that he is overly conscious of maintaining center position during group activities. Various clips showing her standing centrally or holding trophies during encore stages have repeatedly gone viral, fueling discussions about whether she intentionally seeks the spotlight. However, many fans argue that Wonyoung is often judged more harshly than other idols and that ordinary actions are often turned into controversies due to her immense popularity.
Shuhua by dle
Among fourth generation female idols, Shuhua is widely known for her direct and outspoken personality. While many fans appreciate his honesty and willingness to speak his mind, critics often see the same traits as a lack of tact or professionalism.
One of Shuhua’s most talked about controversies occurred during an appearance on a variety show in 2023. Some viewers felt that her responses to the host lacked proper honorifics and appeared less respectful than the behavior of her group members. While supporters point to linguistic and cultural differences, critics argue that public broadcasting requires a higher level of professionalism.
Shuhua has also become known for directly responding to criticism during livestreams and on social media. Whether it’s comments about her appearance, technical issues during broadcasts, or unsolicited advice from viewers, her responses are often candid and unapologetic. Fans typically describe these interactions as fun and authentic. However, detractors argue that his communication style can sometimes come across as overly harsh.
Another debate emerged during the promotion of i-dle “Horn” in 2024, when Shuhua jokingly apologized to the other idols by saying this that summer everyone would only listen to i-dle’s music. While many fans interpreted the remark as playful confidence, others saw it as unnecessarily arrogant.
Although Ningning, Jang Wonyoung, and Shuhua have all been involved in public controversies, many fans argue that labeling them as idols with “Low EQ” oversimplifies complex situations. Most of the incidents cited involve subjective interpretations of short clips, comments or isolated moments rather than serious scandals.
While discussions continue on social media platforms, the debate highlights a larger issue within K-pop fandom culture: the tendency to turn recurring controversies into permanent labels that may not accurately reflect an artist’s personality or intentions.
Ultimately, while criticism of public figures is inevitable, many observers warn that reducing idols to a single narrative may encourage unfair scrutiny rather than balanced discussion.
Sources: K14
